Neuroaesthetics.net

Home › Research

Toward a brain-based theory of beauty: Ishizu & Zeki (2011)

In 2011, Tomohiro Ishizu and Semir Zeki at University College London published one of the most cited studies in neuroaesthetics. It asked a simple question: when we find something beautiful, is there anything in the brain that is common to that experience, whatever the source?

The study

Volunteers rated a set of paintings and a set of musical excerpts as beautiful, indifferent or ugly. They then viewed and listened to the same material while their brain activity was recorded with functional MRI. Because the stimuli came from two different senses, any region that tracked beauty for both could not simply be responding to the features of pictures or of sounds.

What they found

One region stood out: a part of the medial orbitofrontal cortex (mOFC), which the authors called field A1. Activity there was higher for stimuli rated beautiful, and it rose with the intensity of the beauty rating, for both the paintings and the music.

The authors argued this supports a "brain-based theory of beauty". On that view, what different beautiful things share is not a property of the objects themselves but a common neural response in the person experiencing them.

Why it mattered

Limitations

The study was small, as most imaging studies of its time were, and the mOFC responds to many kinds of reward, not only aesthetic ones. Critics point out that this makes it hard to say whether the region encodes beauty specifically or simply value and pleasure in general. Most researchers now treat the finding as evidence that aesthetic experience draws on general-purpose reward systems, rather than as the discovery of a dedicated beauty centre.

Reference

Related: What is neuroaesthetics? · Facial attractiveness research